Table of Contents
Do conversations about screens lead to arguments in your family?
Do you struggle to figure out how much screen time is appropriate at different ages? Do you feel the pull to limit screens more, yet notice that other children seem constantly on iPads or gaming? At the same time, do you worry that restricting screen time will leave your child feeling left out?
These decisions are complex because every child and family is different. When confusion and inner conflict run high, it helps to step back and think it all through. This article looks at how screens affect play, motivation and emotional regulation, and offers connection-based approaches that tend to reduce conflict and support healthier patterns.
Have children lost their appetite for self-directed play?
The connection that’s often missed is that the more time a child spends on screens the more they tend to beg for screen time and the less enthusiastic they become about imaginative play. Screens condition children to fast-paced, brightly coloured entertainment. As a result, many struggle to adjust to the slower pace of ordinary life.
Pleasurable activities of all kinds activate dopamine receptors in the brain. The frequency and intensity of this activation during screen use, however, can leave children dependent on those high-level hits. Everyday activities that require more effort then feel less rewarding, and children become less tolerant of them.
Increased screen time reduces a child’s motivation for self-directed play
Allowing the screens is so tempting for parents desperate for a bit of time and space. Yet, the reality is that the more time children spend on screens, the more it erodes their appetite for self-directed play.
Hence, the more peace parents gain from allowing screen time, the less peace they gain from their child being engaged in self-directed play and activities.
A digital detox often reveals how quickly a child’s intrinsic motivation and curiosity can reawaken
I’ve guided many parents through planning and committing to a digital detox. Pretty consistently I’ve witnessed that when parents either don’t allow or greatly limit screen time, children tend to be more engaged by their play and projects and more able to hold their attention in general. Children become generally more grounded and focused, generally less hyperactive and ultimately the parent generally gets a lot more housework done!
Most parents also notice that when they do a digital detox in the family (be it a full or partial reduction), before long their child tends to again become more engaged in their imaginative play. They wake up in the morning excited to get back to their art, lego, blocks, dress-ups, skate-board tricks or whatever they’re currently engaged by.
Also, teenagers become more creative again when they spend very little time on their screens. We can forget that teenagers lived full lives without screens until just a few years ago in our human history.
Related resources for members:
In these three videos, Parts I, II and III Genevieve tackles the topic of kids begging to be on screens. They cover how to encourage self-directed play and the child’s intrinsic motivation to be creative and to keep following their curiosity. Genevieve discusses how to preserve these instincts. Available to Peaceful Parent Suite Members.
Why meltdowns so often follow screen time
Many parents inadvertently fall into the habit of using screens to soothe their child when they’re upset.
A favourite show or game can seem like a harmless, calming fix. In reality, it often masks rather than reduces stress and can interfere with a child’s developing ability to feel and express emotions. The inactivity that screens induce should not be mistaken for stress relief. Over time, it risks training the habit of zoning out or dissociating when difficult feelings arise.
Screens can give parents a temporary stretch of quiet. An upset child may become still the moment the screen comes on. It is easy to believe this meets the child’s need to de-stress. Yet what many children are actually experiencing is what Dr. Nicholas Kardaras describes as “a hyper-stimulating, dopamine-activating, adrenaline-surging stimulant.” This is very different from the calming effects research shows for practices such as meditation.
When the brain is hyper-stimulated and adrenaline is surging, yet there is little physical or verbal outlet, frustration builds. This helps explain the antsy, disengaged or explosive behaviour many parents notice when screen time ends — and the intense arguments that can follow about getting more time.
Even if you sometimes allow screen time after an upsetting event, it remains important to prioritise holding space first, really listening and giving attention to the child’s upset.
What helps after screen time
Understanding that children often need an outlet for pent-up energy after screens can greatly reduce conflict. Plan something enjoyable and active to follow allotted screen time. Movement, affection and laughter work especially well.
From a peaceful parenting perspective, when an issue repeatedly becomes a source of conflict it is useful to look at the underlying needs the child may be trying to meet. Self-educating about the impacts of screens, combined with sitting down to listen to your child’s feelings on the subject, usually brings greater clarity.
Children need regular activities that genuinely slow them down and help them de-stress.
Quality one-on-one time with a parent is especially powerful, particularly when the child leads and play that’s physical and results in lots of laughter, These activities fill the child’s “love tank,” reduces stress, and reminds them of what they most crave: human connection, love and affection.
Showing genuine interest in their stories, projects and questions also helps them stay engaged with the real world. Reading together, listening to audiobooks or music, and simple shared activities support healthy imagination without the hyper-stimulation of screens.
Play ideas include:
- Board games, card games and ball games
- Arts, crafts and making things
- Unstructured free play
- Time exploring and creating in nature
- Simple projects such as planting and caring for a garden or house plants
Most of the activities many of us remember from our own childhoods still offer excellent engagement and healthy outlets for stress.
Creating agreements tends to lead to more cooperation
Loving limits or creating agreements are approaches that tend to lead to much better outcomes than the more authoritarian approach of rules imposed by consequences. Generally loving limits work better for pre-school aged children. If you do allow your child time on screens or their homework involves screen time, I recommend holding a family meeting and problem-solving together with the aim of making agreements.
Children are dramatically more motivated to work with agreements they’ve contributed to making.
Encourage your child or children to voice their ideas and validate their ideas diplomatically even if you don’t agree. You might, for instance, respond with “Ok so I hear that in your ideal world, you would have unlimited time on the laptop”.
Share your concerns and your suggestions as diplomatically as possible with a calm level tone. For instance, you might explore “Would it be a good idea to make it a rule that nobody in this family turns on a screen in the morning, myself included?”.
Parents also struggle with screen use – share your own struggles
It can help when we share that we also find it hard to manage our time and our impulse control around using screens. You might share that you can feel so disappointed with yourself when you’ve been on the screens too much resulting in not getting things done that needed to be achieved. But also share how important it is to come back to peace with ourselves when we don’t stick with our own limits or expectations.
Watching a movie together as a family
There’s a big difference between your child having screen time alone or with you. Watching something together helps kids maintain the connection with their parent. All that sweet affection and snuggling on the couch are so grounding and de-stressing. When watching a show or film together as a family, we can be vigilant of how our child’s responding emotionally, we can maintain eye contact and smiles and avail of the teachable moments.
The disconnection created by watching screens can be further minimised when family members increase their patience for each person having the right to pause to ask questions or share thoughts and feelings the scene evoked and generally integrate the experience into family communication.
The earlier you develop this habit of pausing the show or game the better. If your child has become attached to an alternative world of video games, maybe start by joining them in this world and open those lines of communication.
Kids need downtime in their busy days
Screens can provide parents a bit of peace and quiet. Kids can crave flopping into that comfortable chair and blobbing out. The upset child becomes immediately quiet when they stare at the screen. Parents often believe that being on screens meets their needs to de-stress and slow down. Yet, in reality, kids are experiencing what Dr Kardaras describes as “a hyper-stimulating, dopamine-activating, adrenaline-surging stimulant”! I’m no scientist but to me that sounds very different from the brain research findings into the effects of meditation on the brain!
Why do so many meltdowns happen at the end of screen time?
So what’s the likely outcome if the brain is hyper-stimulated and all that adrenaline surging puts a kid into a stress response, yet there’s no physical or verbal outlet of all that energy? There’s going to be quite the build-up of frustration. This probably explains all of that out of balance behaviour that happens after children have spent time on screens.
After their children have been on screens most parents notice that instead of being calm, focused and cooperative, their kids are often particularly antsy, disengaged and frustrated. It’s no wonder if all that pent-up frustration gets channelled directly into an argument with their parent about their verging on desperate need for more time on the screen.
What helps to reduce the post-screen time meltdowns
Consider all the underlying needs
From a peaceful parenting perspective, when an issue becomes a source of conflict (as screen usage seems to be in most families) it’s helpful to consider what the underlying needs may be that your child is trying to meet. There are so many contributing factors for parents to consider on this topic and I realise that information regarding screen use can be a lot to process.
From a peaceful parenting perspective, it’s always recommended that parents gain more clarity by both self-educating and also creating the time to sit and listen to their child’s feelings on the subject.
You might also enjoy reading: What every parent needs to know about kids and screens In this article Genevieve shares some of the most up to date research on the impacts of screens. Your child’s time on their screens may be a bigger contributing factor to problem behaviours than you realised.
To be clear with our child, we need to be clear with ourselves
Screens are so addictive and alluring, so it’s understandable that children fight hard to gain more screen time. So if we’re to hold boundaries around screens, we need to feel very confident that our decisions are based on a clear understanding about the impacts on our child, and our family as a whole. It’s easier to be clear with our child when we’re clear with ourselves on how much screen time, if any, we feel comfortable allowing.
An important part of the process of learning more about the impacts of screens on your individual child is to notice any patterns in your child’s behaviour relating to screen use. To this day I have a clear memory of how shocked I was to witness the extremely chaotic behaviour of my then 5-year-old son after watching Star Wars at a friend’s house! This was very valuable information that I couldn’t ignore.
Meeting children’s needs in healthy ways makes them dramatically less vulnerable to excessive screen usage or addiction to video games. The more parents can satisfy their children’s needs for warm and enjoyable connections with family members, this is ultimately what helps to keep kids more engaged in the “real world” than the digital world.
Loving limits
Each parent needs to decide at which age they will allow their children to use screens and generally how much time they will be allowed. If your child is at the age and stage where you do not want them using screens at all, or only on certain days or at certain times, you’ll likely have a lot less conflict if you adopt the principles of loving limits.
Additionally, this article setting limits can bring healing tears gives you guidelines on helping your child through the tough feelings that limits bring up for them.
Nature resets our children
Nature plays a huge part in protecting children from screen addition by reminding them that the natural world makes us feel so good! I highly recommend Florence William’s The Nature Fix as an inspiring reminder that nature restores us and makes us:
“healthier, more creative, more empathetic and more apt to engage with the world and with each other.”
This book is a collection of research on all the hugely therapeutic benefits of spending time in nature; decreased cortisol levels, increase in immune-boosting T cells, improvements for adolescents struggling with learning difficulties, anxiety, depression, PTSD, social phobias, ADHD, ADD, and more.
Genevieve Simperingham is a Psychosynthesis Counsellor, a Parenting Instructor and coach, public speaker, human rights advocate, writer and the founder of The Peaceful Parent Institute. Check out her articles, Peaceful Parenting eCourses, forums and one-year Peaceful Parenting Instructor Training through this website or join over 90,000 followers on her Facebook page The Way of the Peaceful Parent.
I can confirm the value of the above methods with my own 21 year old son who has grown up in this digital age. Compared to his peers, he has very minimal screen time, preferring to do a range of activities he has grown up with. He now works as an adventure leader helping children around ages 11 – 14 appreciate nature, creative play and develop resilience.
In additon to the wise options in this article, there still might need some negotiation and conflict resolution strategies. Some suggestions, once children are aware of your concerns as well as your alternatives to screen time, is to ask children themselves what they think are reasonable limits as well as alternative activities.
Once boundaries of use are negotiated along with alternative activities (including free playtime), you might consider using parental control apps. If so, rather than simply imposing these on your children, aim to reach an agreement about their use and then use lots of praise for engagement in alternative activities during the transition period ad empathising with discomfort with reduced screen time (consider reducing screen time over a period in the same way an addict might reduce drug use overtime to reduce withdrawal effects).
Jon this is so good to read and I really appreciate you taking the time to share this with other readers. It’s very hard to maintain healthy limits around screens when children, so it’s important to keep remembering the long term goals and the patterns being formed. And yes good advice about checking out the parental control apps too!
[…] finish your homework, the natural consequence is that you won’t have the privilege of screen time“. In reality, not allowing the child the screen time they were expecting will be experienced […]
[…] Taking the approach of collaborating and problem-solving with them is likely to have a better result, as teens are developing their autonomy and need to feel good about decisions and changes. It helps to be aware of all the needs it meets for them and also all the effects it has on their development, the positive and the negative. The more a parent can gain a true understanding of what the experience of being online is like for the teenager, the more likely the parent can engage their teen in serious meaningful conversations. […]
[…] of 13 at the time). She started telling me about all the reasons why she feels she really wanted a certain phone. She was making some really good points, but I didn’t reflect that. My rising stress about […]
[…] aggression, bullying, discipline without punishment, alpha children, anxiety, the challenges of parenting in a digital world and so much more. All big […]